« Apparently With a Straight Face | Main | Purging the Few, the Proud »

Comments

Polymath

The question has been raised (in Pharyngula's comment section) about whether Intelligent Divsion has anything to do with the Pythagorean school of thought.

The answer is an emphatic no. As I understand it, the Pythagoreans believed (at least until they secretly proved otherwise) that all numbers had to be rational. But if you take a remainder and express it as a fraction (another division), and take that remainder and make it a fraction, and so on...you get a continued fraction, which can be an irrational number.

This fact provides more support for Intelligent Division: when you deny the possibility of remainders, you can generate all sorts of numbers. Remainderists have to stop calculating once there is a remainder, and then create whole new sets of numbers from scratch. Surely Occam's razor favors the guiding of some supernatural intelligence in the process of division.

Moebius Stripper

I just realized that I had some Intelligent Division proponents in my precalculus class last year. One student emphatically declared that the boat in a question couldn't be rowing at a speed of ten and a half kilometers per hour, because "the speed can't be a fraction."

Alon Levy

Besides, remainderism stops working when you include evidence from more general number fields - just try to divide with remainder in Q[SQRT(-19)].

Xerxes1729

As if you need any further evidence for your argument against Remainderism and Number Theoryism, just think about this:

number theory -> numerology -> witchcraft -> satan

Alternatively,

number theory -> cryptography -> secret messages -> child porn and terrorism

The logic is irrefutable. Number Theorismists have been undone!

vlorbik

all i know is i graded
an algebra paper yesterday where
the solution to 7x = 60
was given as "8 R 4"
(no mention of "x", natch).

and *now* i know why i didn't like it!
remainderism must be eliminated!

Robert Marks

The value of Pi given in 1 Kings 7:23 is a whole number (integer), viz., 3, which is consistent with Intelligent Division. At least no-one can accuse God of being inconsistent.

steve

This looks to be almost as powerful as the recently announced Intelligent Falling theory (http://www.theonion.com/content/node/39512 ).

brian

666=500+100+50+10+5+1
666=600+60+6
666=the sum of 6(10^(n)) from one to three

milo gardner

Remainders were used by 2,000 BCE Egyptians for
subtraction:

2/p - 1/A = (2A -p)/AP

the so called Hultsch-Bruin
method, rediscovered in 1895, used for remainder arithmetic subtraction, or

2/p = Q + R

with R being stated
as a multiple of p,
as (2A -p)/Ap surely
is for scribal division.

Scribal division can be generally shown as inverse
statement of unit fraction series, or one (1) divided by 2 2/3, a quotient and remainder, becomes

1/(8/3) = 3/8 = 1/4 1/8,

as written in the AWT,
RMP, Reisner and every
other ancient hieratic
text.

In addition, in general
Egyptian scribes wrote
out remaindes as unit
fraction series, their
ancient form of numeration
a notation that scholars
have oddly confused, since
most or Classical scholars
accepting odd views of Euclid, that used the same form of unit fraction arithmetic!

That is, rewriting the
history of fractions and
ways of base 10 division,
as you have begun, seems like an odd and misdirected task, and therefore one that hopefully will be abandoned for the traditional 4,000 year old view, ASAP.

Best Regards,

Milo Gardner

D B

Did you forget that division IS only glorified subtraction - just as multiplication IS only glorified addition?

Clinton

Remainder suck therefore they should be eliminated from the surface of the planet. Remainders are crappy baby math (no offense to babies). 16/2 = 4R4 NO. 8 you people. 5/2 2R1 NO 2.5 :( Remainders are for squares. Point Proven.

Clinton

Sorry 'bout that last comment a little crude ;(

RamonGustav

Do you have ideas which worth millions but you lack the necessary capital to put your idea to test?

Buy_Viagra

Do you have a viable business but lack the necessary finances to get it off it’s feet?

Music_master

Hi I liked your note, add your site to your bookmarks.

Hot_cialis

buy cialis buy cialis at a discount buy cialis brand buy cialis by the pill buy cialis canada buy cialis cheap buy cialis cheaper online buy cialis mexico buy cialis omline buy cialis online 20mg buy cialis online site buy cialis online viagra buy cialis pharmacy buy cialis pills generic

guild wars 2 gold

seems like an odd and misdirected task, and therefore one that hopefully will be abandoned for the traditional 4,000 year old view, ASAP.

RX-order

cialis tadalafil cialis tadalafil 100mg cialis tadalafil 20 mg cialis tadalafil american express cialis tadalafil canada cialis tadalafil cialis tadafil tal cialis tadalafil reviews cialis tadalafil viagra cialis tadalafil work cialis the dangers fda cialis the sex pill cialis to buy

Antivirus_man

Merry Christmas! I wish you a lot of gifts and luck in the new year.

JOBS_frend

Hi, I congratulate you on Merry Christmas!

school_dubl

Interesting site, always a new topic .. good luck in the new 2011. Happy New Year!

Realestate

Happy New Year! The author write more I liked it.

Rental

Happy New Year! Happiness and success in 2011.

Rental

Interesting site, always a new topic .. good luck in the new 2011. Happy New Year!

tampa lawyer

I am really appreciating you for your kindness that you have made a really interesting blog, Excellent post and wonderful blog, I really like this type of interesting articles keep it up.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

The .999... Posts That Made Me Briefly Famous

My Feeble Attempts at Humor

Other blogs I like

  • EvolutionBlog
    He writes mostly about evolution, but he's a math guy.
  • Good Math, Bad Math
    Scienceblogs finally has a math guy!
  • Kung Fu Monkey
    A very smart, high-profile screen writer and comic with sensible politics and an amazing ability to rant
  • Math Spectrometer
    My ideas about life, teaching, and politics
  • Pharyngula
    Biology, lefty politics, and strident anti-Intelligent Design
Blog powered by Typepad